
Darkness, Season 1: The Orange Tree is a documentary podcast series telling the story the 2005 murder of 21-year-old Jennifer Cave. The brutal crime scene at the Orange Tree Condos in Austin’s West Campus area shook the city. Two top University of Texas students were convicted and three families’ lives were changed forever. Haley Butler and Tinu Thomas delve into court documents and interview key characters of the murder in this riveting true-crime podcast.
Hosted by: Haley Butler and Tinu Thomas
Episode 3: Vacation
Episode 4: Whodunit
Episode 5: Obsession
Episode 6: Wild Card
Episode 7: Fifteen Years
Our Partners


Meet the Hosts

Haley Butler
A year before The Drag was founded, Haley produced her own podcast about forgotten women’s histories in the closet of her rundown student apartment. Today, she works alongside her co-director Tinu on the Orange Tree and co-teaching a journalism capstone class on audio storytelling.
Tinu Thomas
Tinu joined The Drag as a Director of Audio when it was a budding operation. Along with her co-director Haley Butler, Tinu spent a year reporting, writing, and producing The Orange Tree, The Drag’s debut long-form podcast. Despite her passion for producing clean audio, Tinu’s favorite sound is the crackle before the start of an old film.
Credits
Hosts
Haley Butler
Tinu Thomas
Executive Producer
Robert Quigley
Student Producers
Sydney Jones
Simone Puglia
Candace Baker
Tuesday DerMargosian
Regan Riterbush
Alastair Talbot
Riley Miller
Meredtih Palmer
Kadija Balde
Maya Fawaz
Mikayla Mondragon
Assistant Student
Producers
Lacey Goodman
Taylor Leen
Pooja Patel
Halle Brazda
Caroline Covert
Ana Garcia
Ingrid Garcia
Madison Hager
Will Parker
Jordan Steyer
Armando Perez
Studio Sound Engineer
David Alvarez
KUT Projects Editor
Matt Largey
KUT General Manager
Debbie Hiott
Technical Director
Christian McDonald
Design Director
Madi Thomason
Marketing and Content Director
Sabrina LeBoeuf
Fact Checker
Lisa Roe
Editorial Consultant
Pallavi Kottamasu
Special thanks KXAN, KVUE-TV, The Moody College of Communication, The Dallas Morning News, Todd Callahan, Kathleen McElroy, David J. Neff, Clare Boyle, Alexis Chavez, and all the people who took time to give us feedback and guidance.
Music used in the podcast is from Artlist.io.
Hosts
Haley Butler
Tinu Thomas
Executive Producer
Robert Quigley
Student Producers
Sydney Jones
Simone Puglia
Candace Baker
Tuesday DerMargosian
Regan Riterbush
Alastair Talbot
Riley Miller
Meredtih Palmer
Kadija Balde
Maya Fawaz
Mikayla Mondragon
Assistant Student
Producers
Lacey Goodman
Taylor Leen
Pooja Patel
Halle Brazda
Caroline Covert
Ana Garcia
Ingrid Garcia
Madison Hager
Will Parker
Jordan Steyer
Armando Perez
Studio Sound Engineer
David Alvarez
KUT Projects Editor
Matt Largey
KUT General Manager
Debbie Hiott
Technical Director
Christian McDonald
Design Director
Madi Thomason
Marketing and Content
Director
Sabrina LeBoeuf
Fact Checker
Lisa Roe
Editorial Consultant
Pallavi Kottamasu
Special thanks KXAN, KVUE-TV, The Moody College of Communication, The Dallas Morning News, Todd Callahan, Kathleen McElroy, David J. Neff, Clare Boyle, Alexis Chavez, and all the people who took time to give us feedback and guidance.
Music used in the podcast is from Artlist.io.

Episode 1: The Orange Door